Sales activity throughout St. George Island, Apalachicola, Carrabelle and Eastpoint was up slightly for the Month of May 2025 with 42 total sales – 21 single family homes, 4 condo/town homes, 3 mobile homes, 13 residential home sites and 1 commercial property. Carrabelle saw the most activity with 15 total sales – 1 single family home, 4 condo/town homes, 2 mobile homes and 8 residential home sites. St. George Island had 9 sales of single family homes. Apalachicola had 13 total sales – 7 single family homes, 1 mobile home, 4 residential home sites and 1 commercial lot. Eastpoint had 5 total sales – 4 single family homes and 1 residential home site. Sales prices ranged from a low of $23,000 for a lot located in the City of Carrabelle to $2,050,000 for at six bedroom/5 bath bay front home with private pool and dock located on the East End of St. George Island.
See below a detailed summary of sales by area:
ST GEORGE ISLAND
SINGLE FAMILY HOMES:
MLS# 320380 – 841 E Gorrie Dr – 2 bedroom/2 bath gulf view beach house located in the Gulf Beaches List price – $799,000 Sold price – $776,000 Days on market – 97 Days under contract – 52 Conventional financing Sales to List – 97.1%
MLS# 320938 – 573 W Bay Shore Dr – 3 bedroom/2.5 bath interior beach house with private pool located in the Gulf Beaches List price -$859,000 Sold price – $799,000 Days on market – 79 Days under contract – 21 Conventional financing Sales to List – 93%
MLS# 321174 – 601 E Gorrie Dr – 4 bedroom/2.5 bath 1st tier gulf view beach house with private pool located in the Gulf Beaches List price – $1,075,000 Sold price – $950,000 Days on market – 53 Days under contract – 26 Cash purchase Repair costs concession – $15,000 Sales to List – 88.4%
MLS# 320428 – 433 W Gorrie Dr – 4 bedroom/4 bath 1st tier gulf view beach house with private pool located in the Gulf Beaches List price – $1,295,000 Sold price – $1,165,000 Days on market – 122 Days under contract – 5 Cash purchase Closing Costs concession – $2,954 Repair costs concession – $1,000 Sales to List – 90%
MLS# 321160 – 441 E Gorrie Dr – 3 bedroom/3 bath 1st tier gulf view beach house with private pool located in the Gulf Beaches List price – $1,299,000 Sold price – $1,229,000 Days on market – 59 Days under contract – 29 Conventional financing Sales to List – 94.6%
MLS# 320671 – 764 E Gulf Beach Dr – 4 bedroom/4.5 bath gulf view home with private pool and elevator located in the Gulf Beaches List price – $1,299,000 Sold price – $1,260,000 Days on market – 115 Days under contract – 11 Cash purchase Sales to List – 97%
MLS# 321712 – 355 Cook St – 3 bedroom/2 bath bay front beach house with private pool and private dock located in the Gulf Beaches List price – $1,295,000 Sold price – $1,295,000 Days on market – 7 Days under contract – 27 Cash purchase Sales to List – 100%
MLS# 318217 – 872 W Gorrie Dr – 3 bedroom/2 bath gulf front beach house located in the Gulf Beaches List price – $1,799,000 Sold price – $1,705,000 Days on market – 291 Days under contract – 26 Cash purchase Sales to List – 94.8%
MLS# 321473 – 1823 E Gulf Beach Dr – 6 bedroom/5 bath bay front home with private pool, hot tub and private dock located in Shell Harbor on the East End List price – $2,190,000 Sold price – $2,050,000 Days on market – 5 Days under contract – 32 Conventional financing Sales to List – 93.6%
APALACHICOLA
RESIDENTIAL HOME SITES:
MLS# 321297 – 202 13th St – .14 acre lot located in Greater Apalachicola List price – $45,000 Sold price – $36,000 Days on market – 42 Days under contract – 11 Cash purchase Sales to List – 80%
MLS# 321296 – 161 Ave K – .14 acre lot located in Greater Apalachicola List price – $55,000 Sold price – $44,000 Days on market – 42 Days under contract – 11 Cash purchase Sales to List – 80%
MLS# 321387 – 247 8th St – .28 acre (2 city lots) located in the Historic North side List price – $140,000 Sold price – $115,000 Days on market – 40 Days under contract – 30 Cash purchase Sales to List – 82.1%
MLS# 321419 – Lots 6 & 7 10th St – .28 acre lot located in the Historic North side List price – $198,000 Sold price – $180,000 Days on market – 34 Days under contract – 23 Cash purchase Sales to List – 90.9%
SINGLE FAMILY/MOBILE HOMES:
MLS# 321654 – 555 Oyster Rd – 2 bedroom/1 bath older mobile home located in Greater Apalachicola List price – $89,900 Sold price – $88,000 Days on market – 4 Days under contract – 32 Cash purchase Sales to List – 97.9%
MLS# 318468 – 187 Ave L – 2 bedroom/1 bath Florida cottage located on the Historic North side List price – $220,000 Sales price – $210,000 Days on market – 250 Days under contract – 28 FHA financing Sales to List – 95.5%
MLS# 319864 – 201 12th St – 2 bedroom/1 bath renovated Florida Cottage located on the Historic North side List price – $269,000 Sold price – $262,000 Days on market – 167 Days under contract – 44 Conventional financing Closing costs concession – $1,000 Sales to List – 97.4%
MLS# 320028 – 114 & 116 10th St – Two 2 bedroom/2 bath renovated Florida Cottages located on the Historic North side List price – $399,000 Sold price – $328,500 Days on market – 182 Days under contract – 28 Cash purchase Repair costs concession – $3,000 Sales to List – 82.3%
MLS# 320816 – 140 Ave D – 3 bedroom/2 bath home located on the Historic South side List price – $450,000 Sold price – $430,000 Days on market – 93 Days under contract – 15 Cash purchase Sales to List – 95.6%
MLS# 320220 – 203 9th St – 2 bedroom/2 bath newer construction Florida Cottage sold with adjacent vacant lot located on the Historic North side List price – $460,000 Sold price – $440,000 Days on market – 134 Days under contract – 22 Cash purchase Sales to List – 95.7%
MLS# 317875 – 76 Ave G – 3 bedroom/3 bath renovated Queen Anne cottage located on the Historic North side List price – $535,000 Sold price – $535,000 Days on market – 222 Days under contract – 115 FHA financing Closing costs concession – $20,000 Sales to List – 100%
MLS# 321601 – 137 Bay Colony Way – 3 bedroom/2.5 bath home with private pool located in Bay Colony subdivision in Greater Apalachicola List price – $599,000 Sold price – $599,000 Conventional financing Closing costs concession – $11,980 Sales to List – 100%
COMMERCIAL:
MLS# 320622 – TBD 4th St – .14 acre commercial lot located in Downtown Apalachicola List price – $129,900 Sold price – $110,000 Days on market – 16 Days under contract – 103 Assumed financing Sales to List – 84.7%
CARRABELLE
RESIDENTIAL HOME SITES:
MLS# 321758 – 605 Tallahassee St – .13 acre lot located in the City of Carrabelle List price – $25,000 Sold price – $23,000 Days on market – 2 Days under contract – 13 Cash purchase Sales to List – 92%
MLS# 321757 – 603 Tallahassee St – .13 acre lot located in the City of Carrabelle List price – $25,000 Sold price – $25,000 Days on market – 3 Days under contract – 16 Cash purchase Sales to List – 100%
MLS# 320460 – 131 Indiana St – .18 acre bay view lot located in Lanark List price – $42,000 Sold price – $37,500 Days on market – 130 Days under contract – 17 Cash purchase Sales to List – 89.3%
MLS# 317549 – 138 Indiana St – .12 acre lot located in Lanark List price – $60,000 Sold price – $50,000 Days on market – 354 Days under contract – 27 Cash purchase Sales to List – 83.3%
MLS# 321563 – 2098 Lighthouse Rd – 1.01 acre lot located in Lighthouse Ridge in Carrabelle List price – $55,000 Sold price – $52,500 Days on market – 12 Days under contract – 32 Cash purchase Sales to List – 95.5%
MLS# 321533 – 1562 Carraway Ct – .07 acre canal front lot located in Carraway Bay in Carrabelle List price – $69,000 Sold price – $69,000 Days on market – 1 Days under contract – 39 Conventional financing Sales to List – 100%
MLS# 319924 – 1981 Hwy 98 W – 1.01 acre bay view lot located in Crooked River Lighthouse Estates subdivision in Carrabelle List price – $125,000 Sold price – $113,000 Days on market – 186 Days under contract – 33 Cash purchase Sales to List – 90.4%
MLS# 321891 – 272 Frank McKamey Way – 4.25 acre lot located in Destiny’s Subdivision in Carrabelle List price – $125,000 Sold price – $125,000 Days on market – 1 Days under contract – 35 Conventional financing Sales to List – 100%
SINGLE FAMILY/CONDO/TOWN HOMES/MOBILE HOMES:
MLS# 321890 – TBD Hwy 67 – 3 bedroom/2 bath mobile home sold with no land included List price – $50,000 Sold price – $50,000 Entered for comp purposes only
MLS# 321693 – 10-7 Pine St – 1 bedroom/1 bath “fixer-upper” unit in Lanark Village List price – $79,900 Sold price – $55,000 Days on market – 16 Days under contract – 21 Cash purchase Sales to List – 68.8%
MLS# 320399 – 10-8 W Pine St – 1 bedroom/1.5 bath renovated unit in Lanark Village List price – $127,900 Sold price – $120,000 Days on market – 130 Days under contract – 22 Seller financing Sales to List – 93.8%
MLS# 321486 – 12-3 Parker Ave – 2 bedroom/1 bath renovated unit in Lanark Village List price – $139,000 Sold price – $130,000 Days on market – 17 Cash purchase Sales to List – 93.5%
MLS# 321920 – 27-1 Parker Ave – 1 bedroom/1 bath renovated unit in Lanark Village List price – $148,900 Sold price – $140,000 Days on market – 1 Days under contract – 27 Cash purchase Sales to List – 94%
MLS# 321352 – 309 NW 5th St – 1 bedroom/1 bath Florida Cottage located in Pickett’s Addition in Carrabelle List price – $159,900 Sold price – $152,000 Days on market – 7 Days under contract – 41 Cash purchase Sales to List – 95%
MLS# 321549 – 106 Connecticut St – 3 bedroom/2 bath bay view mobile home located in Lanark List price – $195,000 Sold price – $180,000 Days on market – 34 Days under contract – 16 Cash purchase Sales to List – 92.3%
EASTPOINT
RESIDENTIAL HOME SITES:
MLS# 320978 – 313 Blue Heron Dr – 1.02 acre lot located in Magnolia Ridge subdivision List price – $57,000 Sold price – $54,000 Days on market – 64 Days under contract – 27 Cash purchase Sales to List – 94.7%
SINGLE FAMILY HOMES:
MLS# 320471 – 256 Creamer St – 3 bedroom/2 bath home located in David Brown Estates List price – $275,000 Sold price – $260,000 Days on market – 46 Days under contract – 71 Cash purchase Sales to List – 94.5%
MLS# 318161 – 274 Ridgecrest Pkwy – 3 bedroom/2 bath new construction home located in Magnolia Ridge subdivision List price – $369,000 Sold price – $359,000 Days on market – 298 Days under contract – 20 Cash purchase Sales to List – 97.3%
MLS# 320121 – 347 Gladiola Way – 3 bedroom/2 bath new construction home located in Magnolia Ridge subdivision List price – $390,000 Sold price – $380,000 Days on market – 139 Days under contract – 44 Conventional financing Sales to List – 97.4%
MLS# 321625 – 223 N Bay Shore Dr – Two bay front homes – Main house and guest cottage offering 2 bedrooms and 3 baths with private dock sitting on 8.74 acres located in Magnolia Bluff List price – $1,895,995 Sold price – $1,700,000 Days on market – 6 Days under contract – 37 Seller financing Sales to List – 89.7%
